|Main > Kyrgyzstan > Analysis|
AKIPRESS.COM - "Central Asia is crumbling," according to Business Insider, a German-owned American news website.
The speed and extent of this leans in part on political and economic shifts in Russia, China, Afghanistan, and more. Geography is the main reason outside forces are shaping the growth of Central Asia.
Always trapped between major powers such as Russia and China, Central Asia is at risk of war.
The region goes from the Caspian Sea in the west to the Tien Shan Mountains in the south and the Altay Mountains in the east. The ranges split the region from Afghanistan in the south and China in the east. Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, and Turkmenistan are mostly flat. Tajikistan and Kyrgyzstan are hilly.
In the north lies the vast Kazakh Steppe. Kazakhstan shares a flat, 3,000-mile border with Russia. And like we wrote about in “Russia’s Strategy,” a border the country can’t defend.
Yet even Central Asian countries distant from Russia and cut off from China by mountains are weak. Since the late 600s, native Turkic forces, powers that held Persia (like Arabs and Turks), and the Chinese have all at some point run parts of the region.
Years of war and foreign rule led to the growth of weak states with deep inner soft spots in Central Asia. The region’s modern borders are due to Soviet planners drawing them in the 1920s and 1930s.
So, they are not innate. They do not quite show ethnic or national divides. For example, about 23% of Kazakhstan are ethnic Russians. Ethnic Uzbeks make up about 14% of Kyrgyzstan and over 13% of Tajikistan. Central Asia is a region of great ethnic and regional stress. They risk the unity of modern states.
They risk the unity of modern states.
Scare Resources Lead to Wars
Geography and Soviet infrastructure planning lend to ongoing stress with the five Central Asian states. The main stress is strong fighting over scarce resources like water. The region needs two rivers, the Syr Darya and Amu Darya.
Under Soviet rule, the upstream countries (Tajikistan and Kyrgyzstan) gave water to the rest of the region through a centrally run plan. This managed the use of a reservoir and water distribution levels in the region based on Soviet economic goals.
Other countries, in turn, gave energy to resource-poor Tajikistan and Kyrgyzstan. After the fall of the USSR, fears grew—especially in Uzbekistan—over upstream countries using water for power generation.
Scarce resources, population growth, and the use of energy and water to barter can heighten ethnic and border tensions. Especially in the lush and populous Fergana Valley. It is spread among Uzbekistan, Tajikistan, and Kyrgyzstan.
Afghanistan Actors Threaten Central Asia
The region’s nearness to Afghanistan adds chaos. The US drawdown, plus an incoherent state, has let armed non-state actors to again rule Afghanistan. This then threatens Central Asia.
Afghanistan borders three Central Asian states: Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan, and Tajikistan. The country is now trying to return to its factional roots. With the US taking out most of its troops, the government in Kabul is up against a fast-growing Taliban insurgency.
In fact, the government is just one faction among many. The region’s governments fear militants and violence spilling over. Also, Central Asian militants crossing into Afghanistan to meet with groups from the Taliban to the Islamic State working in the country—which we’ve written about at length. These militants could get training and arms that could be put to use in Central Asia. Central Asian militants are now fighting with IS and others in Syria and Iraq. They risk safety in their home states.
Geography is at the root of Central Asia’s battles. It is fraught with tensions over ethnicity, Soviet-drawn borders, and high competition for resources. Plus, this complex and divided area is open to outside forces. Crises in nearby countries cause chaos in the region.